Thursday, September 29, 2016

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Parts One and Two



Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Parts One and Two is first and foremost a play. Plays tend to read differently than normal fictional books in that setting and world are less lush and richly defined. Plays are heavily dialogue driven with some stage cues. Which, to me, makes this less fun of a Harry Potter book because the actual world of Harry Potter is essentially left unpainted, not just leaving a little to the imagination, but almost everything to the imagination in terms of appearance and setting. (Some people might like this, I am not usually a fan.)

A little bit of spoiling may follow…

The plot is heavily focused on difficulties in the relationship Harry has with his son Albus Severus. There is also a lot of time travel and foibles associated with time travel (I may have been singing “Let’s do the time warp again!” in my head as I was reading through this). Having Voldemort’s daughter as a character definitely made things more interesting.

But to me the character development in the play was very shallow, which to be fair there is nowhere near the room in a play for character depth and development the way there is in a novel, let alone seven novels and a rather developed universe. I will admit though, there is some character development or depth added to Harry Potter in being the boy who lived (on multiple occasions).

In many ways I would love to see Harry Potter universe / world novels that essentially leave the boy alone, something more enthralling and with more depth than the other shorter books / plays. (I have the same critique of the Star Wars movies and the fact that we are too often dealing with the Skywalker family, here’s hoping for Rogue One. But the expanded universe, though what is actually cannon anymore is crazy and could be many posts in its own right, at least departed from our main characters and I would love for the Harry Potter universe to do the same.)

If you are a big Harry Potter fan, read it, it is good. If not, I would not say it is a must read or particularly transformative or immersive for the Potter-verse.

No comments:

Post a Comment